Elegant dining room at Rare Steakhouse in New York City with crystal chandeliers.

Rare Steakhouse New York City

Rare Steakhouse sits at 14 W Mifflin St. It is a fifteen-minute walk from MoMA, a distance that keeps it clear of the dense tourist traffic surrounding the midtown museum district.

The room runs smart, favoring a traditional, classic grill atmosphere over the high-volume flash of the nearby Fifth Avenue corridors. While mid-priced dining often invites inconsistency, the 4.60 guest rating across 698 reviews suggests a reliable precision that its neighbors near Times Square frequently sacrifice. It provides a more composed environment for a romantic dinner, trading the area’s frenetic energy for a grounded, quiet service.

Photos & Videos

© Photo Credits: Rare Steakhouse

Highlights

Cuisine

Rare Steakhouse FAQ

Rare Steakhouse specializes in traditional, classic grill cuisine. The venue offers a fine dining environment that includes romantic seating and views. Guests consistently rate the restaurant highly, with a 4.60 rating based on 698 reviews. The atmosphere is designed for those seeking a formal meal, and the dress code is smart and elegant, which aligns with the overall aesthetic of the space. It is a well-regarded choice for visitors who appreciate a traditional steak dinner in a thoughtful, established setting.

You can find Rare Steakhouse located at 14 W Mifflin St in Madison. The location is situated within walking distance of several major sites, making it convenient for those exploring the city. You can reach both Times Square and the Museum of Modern Art within a fifteen-minute walk. If you plan to visit the shops on Fifth Avenue, you can expect a twenty-minute walk from the restaurant. Its position allows for easy travel between dining and local sightseeing.

A meal at Rare Steakhouse falls into a moderate price range, categorized as a two-dollar-sign experience. This reflects a mid-level cost that sits between budget-friendly options and the most expensive dining in the city. The pricing provides a balance for those looking for a traditional, well-reviewed steakhouse experience without the high costs of more expensive, top-tier venues. With a high guest rating of 4.60, the pricing is generally seen as a fair value for the dining experience offered.

New York Conciergerie can help you coordinate your visit to Rare Steakhouse alongside your broader city itinerary. Because the venue is located within a fifteen-minute walk of landmarks like Times Square and the Museum of Modern Art, we can provide guidance on timing your dinner to align with your other activities. We help manage the logistics of your visit, ensuring that your evening plans align effectively with your time spent at this traditional, well-regarded grill.

Opening Hours

Sunday

Closed

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

16:00 - 21:00

Wednesday

16:00 - 21:00

Thursday

16:00 - 21:00

Friday

16:00 - 21:00

Saturday

16:00 - 21:00

Location

14 W Mifflin St, Madison, WI 53703

Nearby

Times Square800 m
Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)1.0 km
Fifth Avenue1.5 km
Central Park2.5 km

Additional Information

Name

Rare Steakhouse New York City

Establishment Type

Restaurant

Cuisine Type

Grills, Traditional, Classic

Dress Code

Smart and Elegant

Price Range

$$

Address

14 W Mifflin St, Madison, WI 53703

This is an independently maintained listing. Rare Steakhouse is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by New York Conciergerie. Are you the owner? Claim this listing

Explore New York City

Overview
New YorkConciergerie

All venue names and trademarks are property of their respective owners. Listings are independently compiled for informational purposes only and do not imply endorsement or affiliation.

© 2026 New York Conciergerie. All rights reserved.